Too Close to Call


"For the bulls, the S&P needs to move above $1,375, the CRB commodities index must generate another leg up and gold must make a higher high by reclaiming the $1,622/oz level. These are the bullish lines in the sand."

Is it a bear market, or is it a bull market? That is the question.

On one hand Europe is obviously in a recession. China is slowing dramatically, and the U.S. economy is clearly in "stall mode" at best, and slowing rapidly at worst. That alone would suggest that a bear market has begun.

On top of that, the S&P broke through its daily cycle trend line today (although it did manage to rally back before the close).


A break of the trend line usually indicates that the daily cycle has started its decline into a cycle low. If this turns out to be the case, then this cycle would have topped on day 21, which gives it quite a few days to move down into the cycle bottom. (Average daily cycle length trough to trough is about 35 to 40 days). If it does turn out that the cycle topped on the 21st day, then there is a strong chance of testing the June lows at the next daily cycle bottom.

As a matter of fact, I think if we break below the June 25 half-cycle low, it will indicate that the intermediate cycle has topped and we should break below the June bottom if not during this daily cycle then probably a sharp break below that level during the next daily cycle.

On the other hand, there are quite a few bullish signs that are popping up.

For starters, this is an election year. Does anyone really think that the politicians won't pull out all the stops to try and keep the economy and markets inflated up until the election?

Next, the advance-decline line managed to make a new high even though the S&P was still 3% below its 52-week high. As Jason Goephert at sentiment has pointed out, this has almost always lead to new highs. As a matter of fact, Jason noted that since 1940 there have been 13 similar occurrences and all but one led to the market making new highs within 3 months, on average within 18 days of the advance-decline line breakout.


Another positive is that the CRB's rally out of its three year cycle low appears to be consolidating in a bull flag in preparation for another leg up. If stocks are caught in a bear market then the CRB should be rolling over rather quickly.bullscents3

Oil is also resisting the short-term weakness in the stock market and appears to be consolidating the initial $10 thrust off its intermediate bottom, and preparing for another leg up.


A different but related vein of thought is the U.S. dollar index. Today was the 16th day of the dollar's daily cycle (average duration 18 to 28 days). This being the case, it's getting late enough in the cycle that the dollar should start to move down again any time now. A major concern for bears would be any move lower by the dollar as risk assets tend to trade inversely.

An even bigger concern is dollar sentiment. It is currently at levels that have generated intermediate tops almost without fail in the past.


Chart courtesy of sentiment

The fact that we still haven't seen a left translated daily cycle out of the dollar makes me think that the dollar still has an intermediate decline ahead of it. This week will be the 17th week in an intermediate cycle that usually runs 18 to 25 weeks and there's a good chance this sentiment extreme is going to force an intermediate top as soon as this daily cycle runs out of steam.

A possible negative is the fact that gold seems unable to gain any upside traction in this new intermediate cycle. If the CRB has formed a three-year cycle low, why isn't gold generating any upside momentum?

If gold were to drop below $1,547/ounce it would indicate that a left translated daily cycle is in progress and as many of you know a left translated daily cycle often indicates that the intermediate cycle has topped as well.

Another negative is the fact that mining stocks as represented by the GDX ETF did move below their prior daily cycle bottoms. The one small sign of hope is the reversal Thursday, which if it holds above the May lows could indicate that miners are just moving through a 1-2-3 reversal, and this was the #2 test of the lows.


Of course, we won't know whether this is in fact what is happening until miners either break below the May bottom or move back above the June high.

For the bulls the S&P needs to move above 1,375, the CRB must generate another leg up, and gold must make a higher high by reclaiming the $1,622/oz level. These are the bullish lines in the sand.

The bears need to see the stock market drop below the half cycle low of 1310, the CRB must break downwards out of its consolidation, and gold has to drop below $1,547/oz.

I think the appropriate position for traders at the moment is to stay in cash until we see which one of these lines are going to be crossed first.

Toby Connor
Gold Scents

Get Our Streetwise Reports Newsletter Free

A valid email address is required to subscribe