So, why is gold as collateral such an important step for gold in the global monetary system?
The Latest Moves
Last week, the European Parliament's Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs agreed to allow central counterparties to accept gold as collateral. Once ratified, we would see gold redefined as a highly liquid asset under the Capital Requirements IV Directive, due in June from the European Commission. This is not the first time gold has been accepted as collateral. Late in 2010 ICE Clear Europe, a leading European derivatives clearinghouse became the first clearinghouse in Europe to accept gold as collateral. In February of this year, JP Morgan became the first bank to accept gold bullion as collateral. The Chicago Mercantile Exchange is now accepting gold as collateral for certain trades and the London-based clearinghouse LCH Clearnet has said it also plans to start accepting gold as collateral later this year subject to regulatory approval.
Why Now?
Despite comforting words from the U.S. the Eurozone, government debt is being regarded with somewhat less enthusiasm than in the past. Both monetary zones are experiencing awful problems regarding their debt, particularly on the international front. A look at the Mediterranean members of the EU shows nations either unable to repay their debts or on the brink. This makes their debt dubious collateral. The sight of the EU wanting to control taxation—sell state-owned assets on condition that more funds are poured into the country—really is what happens when an individual is liquidated (sequestrated)—nothing short of that. Will Greece accept this without some dramatic moves? If Greece had lost a war, this would be the spoils. That is certainly how the Greek people will see it.
Are debtor obligations more important than national sovereignty? The answer is not as apparent as it seems. If they are, at the very least, social unrest is likely, which, in turn, will further damage one of its main sources of revenues—tourism. But Greek voters are aware (as is much of their government) that Greece retains jurisdiction over Greek assets in the country. It is Greece's decision, not the EU's.
Other potential reactions may include:
- Refusal to accept anything but a 50% debt write-off and leave the banks to sort themselves out.
- Leaving the EU with the obligations unmet or a massive extension to the maturity dates made by the Greek government.
- Reinstating the drachma and making holidays in Greece very cheap, as inflation takes off, euro prices drop and Greece experiences a boom in tourism.
No doubt, the Greeks are weighing all these options and will do what best serves Greek interests in the end. Let's glance at the dominant principles that will guide the process in the days and weeks ahead.
On the banking side, the concept of debt re-scheduling is unacceptable because it would reduce the asset base of the banks and undermine their solvency. The extension of debt and lowering of interest rates would overcome that problem, but it is paramount that the debt be repaid eventually, in a manner that an impoverished Greece can bear. The sell-off of state-owned assets will reduce state revenues and likely cause a tremendous amount of employment cutting (as the operations are made profitable) which will exacerbate the situation. The severity of a new debt package will hurt Greece and ensure that its economic woes last for up to a generation.
On the Greek side, the principles of democracy demand that Greek populations act in the interest of the voting public, which means the government must assess whether the solutions are acceptable to the public. If they lead to the nation's impoverishment for a generation, the Greek public won't accept them. A pragmatic assessment of the worst of the two situations must be made, an onerous set of repayments, or the loss of financial credibility in the EU and the ejection of Greece from the EU (may be the lesser evil).
Such an isolation of the country may raise employment and improve tourism just as sanctions in relatively developed nations often produce a boom. Whatever the outcome, you can be sure that politicians will follow voter's first, ahead of banking requirements.
Whatever happens, it will prove very bad for the EU and the euro. Would you accept its debt as collateral? Unlikely! What's worse is that any attempt to seize Greek assets without its approval may see the country take itself out of the Eurozone. Would the EU actually invade to take Greek assets in payment of unpaid debts? A significant write-off of what's owed may be a disaster, but it may well be the only option left.
This may well prove to be a battle of 'bankers' against democracy!
Greek Gold
Of critical interest to the gold markets is the sight of Greek gold. Greece currently owns 111.5 tons of gold in its reserves㭋.3% of its reserves—which can be taken out of its reach and into the hands of creditors. The sale of its government-owned assets to private hands under the pressure of distressed finances may well not achieve anywhere near their value. Would the Greek government pay the proceeds across to creditors immediately? Their gold has far more value than its current market price.
Already Gone?
But has it already been used as collateral in a Bank of International Settlement deal where it was swapped for foreign currencies? Last year the BIS undertook many gold/currency swaps in mysterious, undisclosed situations. Were they tied to the bailouts? There will be no more devastating a blow to Greece's financial credibility than a disclosure that the gold has already gone. It's equivalent to the family jewels being sold off. And that is gold's value, not its market price!
The current gold price is irrelevant to the repayment of debt. 111.5 tons is worth only $5.5 billion, which barely scratches the surface of Greece's $350 billion debt. In a situation where monetary values are collapsing (the UN has just issued a report in which they state their fears of a U.S. dollar collapse) the gold price will leap to levels where national debt becomes relatively easy to repay and certainly worth all the promises a government can make at that time. Gold in extreme situations adds considerable credibility and value to any debt situations, way beyond its market price.
If the gold is there, then Greece would feel that it is the one asset that it can use when all credibility is lost. That's why central banks hold so much gold in the first place! If Greece was to leave the Eurozone, Greece might have a chance, with its gold, to transition into a more prosperous country.
Other Countries in Distress
A look at the other debt-distressed nations that have received a bailout or may want a bailout:
- Ireland has only 6 tons of gold in its reserves, which (in current prices) is worth only $296M. Ireland needs far more to solve its debt problems. The gold would be symbolic of the nation's family jewels. The cleverest move Ireland has made was to insist on its low Corporation Taxes being maintained because this will allow much higher revenues to be achieved.
- Portugal is in a different category; it has 382.5 tons of gold in its reserves, which has a current market value of $18.9 billion—that would make a significant contribution to its debt situation.
- Spain has 281.6 tons, the value of which at current prices is worth $13.9 billion. Again, this would make a significant contribution to its debt repayment.
- Belgium has 227.5 tons with a current market value of $11.2 billion.
- The UK has 310.3 tons of gold remaining in its vaults, which is worth $15.3 billion.
- Italy, which has just come under the ratings agency's spotlight, holds 2,541.8 tons of gold in its reserves, worth $121 billion at current values.
- With the UN placing the U.S. dollar in the potential collapse category—a glance at the published level of gold reserves shows it holds 8,133.5 tons of gold, worth $4.01 trillion at current prices.
- What if the crisis spread and the EU gold reserves at the ECB came under threat? Its 502.1 tons of gold, valued at today's prices, is $24.78 billion.
Having shown you these figures, we must stress that such gold reserves will be used only if there are no alternatives. It is a last resort asset that, when gone, leaves the nation (almost) out of the international arena and in an (almost) isolated position. In some cases, this may prove a good thing. An extreme example of this was seen when Rhodesia had international sanctions placed against it. It thrived, as all the imports had to be substituted for the local equivalents. South Africa, in the face of sanctions, also thrived. So, you can be sure that some nations will be tempted to default rather than sacrifice their gold reserves.
As we noted, they may well have been pledged already via the gold/currency swaps last year. And current acceptance of gold as collateral is preparing the way for the publication of deals after the event.
Gold as Collateral
How it will affect the gold /silver markets?
Subscribers only; subscribe through www.GoldForecaster.com and www.SilverForecaster.com.
Legal Notice/Disclaimer: This document is not, and should not, be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to purchase or subscribe for any investment. Gold Forecaster - Global Watch/Julian D. W. Phillips/Peter Spina, have based this document on information obtained from sources it believes to be reliable but which it has not independently verified; Gold Forecaster - Global Watch/Julian D. W. Phillips/Peter Spina make no guarantee, representation or warranty and accepts no responsibility or liability as to its accuracy or completeness. Expressions of opinion are those of Gold Forecaster - Global Watch/Julian D. W. Phillips/Peter Spina only and are subject to change without notice. Gold Forecaster - Global Watch/Julian D. W. Phillips/Peter Spina assume no warranty, liability or guarantee for the current relevance, correctness or completeness of any information provided within this Report and will not be held liable for the consequence of reliance upon any opinion or statement contained herein or any omission. Furthermore, we assume no liability for any direct or indirect loss or damage or, in particular, for lost profit, which you may incur as a result of the use and existence of the information, provided within this Report.
