Scotland Dithering over Nuclear Power Plants


"There is no more time for discussion, these power plants should be under construction right now."

It saddens us to read an article today on, by Environment Correspondent, Jenny Haworth, regarding whether or not nuclear power stations should be built in Scotland. By 2015 the UK will be entering a very tricky period of DE-commissioning the current crop of nuclear plants along with a few old coal-burning power plants with no operationally ready power source to bridge the gap. There is no more time for discussion, these power plants should be under construction right now.

This is a snippet from the article:

THE head of a new climate-change body that will advise the Scottish Government has disagreed with Alex Salmond's decision not to build nuclear power stations.

Lord Adair Turner, chairman of the Committee on Climate Change, said he thinks all options for providing electricity should be left open, including the creation of new nuclear power plants.

Speaking to The Scotsman ahead of a visit to Scotland on Monday, when he will give a talk on climate change, Lord Turner said: "It is an emotive issue, but at the UK level, there will be a commitment to nuclear. We think it should not be ruled out.

"The Scottish Government has to make its own decisions, but we think the challenge of dealing with climate change is so big that we should be very wary of ruling out any option that is available."

The Scottish Government is aiming to rely on a mix of renewables and "clean" fossil fuel power stations which use technology to capture and store carbon dioxide emissions to provide the country's electricity.

We have been talking about these alternative solutions since I was a school kid in short pants. They just don't get it do they? If and when these new technologies become available and are able to provide large quantities of power then we can give it a shot, but they are not proven and to our way of thinking they are not even on the list for consideration.

However, Mr. Salmond, Scotland's First Minister is quoted as saying: "Anything you invest and it will be billions in nuclear power is billions taken away from clean technology and in renewable technology."

Energy Minister Jim Mather added that renewables backed up by "clean thermal baseload" could meet Scotland's energy needs many times over and create thousands of jobs.

The building of nuclear power stations also creates lots of jobs. Scotland could build a number of nuclear power stations and sell the surplus electricity to England and Europe, just as the French do now, and create an income stream for the next three decades. This is an opportunity that will be regretted by the Scots.

Meanwhile, over in Sweden, they have decided to scrap the 30-year ban on new nuclear power stations. Three cheers for the Swedes, at long last another country sees the light.

Swedish public opinion polls have shown growing support for nuclear energy due to the lack of alternatives to replace the country's 10 nuclear plants, that supply about 50% of the country's electricity.

Related Articles

Get Our Streetwise Reports Newsletter Free

A valid email address is required to subscribe